CBI Archive

Idol Thoughts 10/24

Wednesday, October 24th, 2007 at 1:53 AM EST

Updated: Wednesday, October 24th, 2007 at 1:53 AM EST

Let’s take a look at what folks have cooking in the Play at Home thread on CBR’s Artist and Writer Showcase forum!

I am going to post all their first pages (of their three page assignment). For reference, here is the script by C.B. Cebulski for that first page…

PAGE ONE

Page One, Panel One

We open here with a shot of cheerleaders, which, as we all know, is how every good comic should open! Anyway… we’re on the sidelines of a high school football game as these hot young things are doing their best to do their jobs and cheer on the crowd. The main focus of this shot should be one cheerleader in particular and she should be the center of attention; clearly the captain and the hottest of the bunch. Poses and uniforms up to you, but they should look sexy and feature the letters JB as I went to Joel Barlow High School.

Caption: I never dated a cheerleader.

Page One, Panel Two

Cut now to a scene at the prom… just a close-up of the prom queen as she stands on the stage and smiles and holds her flowers and waves at the crowd. She just got her crown and is happy as all hell. She’s the prom queen, so she should be hot and decked out here in her gown with her tiara. I can send my prom pic as ref if you want to see what my date wore in 1989, even though she wasn’t even nominated as queen. Depending on how you frame it, if we can see any of the background, it should be of balloons and glitter and all that prom shit, with any signs again for Joel Barlow High School Prom or JBHS 1989. Our theme was “Wonderful Tonight” if you wanted to include that. I’m just giving details here, so feel free to use or disregard whatever you want.

Caption: Never got lucky with the prom queen.

Page One, Panel Three

Cut to the outside of the back of a schoolyard near a parking lot. There should be a couple of old wooden benches and on them are seated a bunch of stoner chicks. Back then, Jerry Garcia was alive and the Dead were still touring and there were plenty of Deadhead chicks at my school. So there should be three or four of these chicks seated here, ripped jeans, tie-dyed shirts, flip-flops, rings, bracelets, anklets, dreadlocks, braided hair… however far you feel like going. They’re all just sitting around smoking cigs and chatting as an old boom box plays some tunes they’re grooving to.

Caption: Those kinds of girls always required too much effort.

Caption: I always found it easier to trade cigarettes with the stoner chicks for a quick hook-up in the parking lot.

Page One, Panel Four

This is a small inset panel in the bottom right corner of panel three. It’s a simple shot of a young C.B. here, smiling or winking at the reader, as he enters the story.

C.B.: Just kidding.

Page One, Panel Five

Establishing shot of C.B. here now, dressed much like he is on the cover of Wonderlost #1: jeans, t-shirt, sambas, Rossignol cap, and black and yellow JB soccer jacket. He’s on his own, maybe holding a notebook and a text book under one arm, as he walks down a crowded high school hallway lined with lockers.

Caption: I mean, sure, I was your typical, horny high school teen, looking for love in any place I could find it.

Caption: Most often in the pants of any girl who’d let me in.

Page One, Panel Six

C.B. now standing in the same hallway in front of the lockers with a cute little dark-haired hottie, dressed casually in jeans and sweater and Keds or something similar. She has her back up against the lockers as he leans in and over her and they make goo-goo eyes at each other.

Caption: But now that I’m older, reflecting back on all the different girls I dated…

Caption: …I’ve come to realize that the ones I slept with are the ones I remember the least.

Page One, Panel Seven

Tighter on just their faces as they stare in each other’s eyes.

Caption: My fondest memories are of the girls I didn’t hook up with.

Caption: The small moments I shared with them are the ones I’ve never forgotten.

Here is a page from “Club Samich”…

club samich.jpg

Here is one by “DFY”…

dfy.jpg

Here is a page from Jun Bob Kim…

junbobkim.jpg

Here is one by Maxmen Chuen…

maxmen chuen.jpg

Here is a page from “polystyleneman”…

polystyleneman.jpg

And, once again, here is a page from Comic Book Idol 1’s own Chris Ring!!

chris ring.jpg


3 Comments

polystyleneman and Chris Ring Rock.

I love their Layout and expressions on the young faces they draw.

Really cool stuff from these two here.

http://hotaircoldlove.blogspot.com/2007/10/comic-book-idol-3-shortlist.html

I am only going to comment on the last page considering it was my favorite of the bunch.

Panel 1.
Nice shot…perspective is off with the BG characters which throws the panel off completely.
The cheer-leader in the FG seems to have the most done on her I am assuming to give the panel depth..not bad..but the anatomy and over-all body-language is lacking.

Panel 2.
Don’t know why this panel had to have a tilt to it?..Tilts and whatnot need to be saved for action sequences and pan shots that require more room.(Dynamics mostly).Alot more could have been done for this shot instead of a lone figure.Anatomy and gesture again needs work.

Panel 3.
Beside’s an explantion in the script..I don’t know where we are!..girls with smokes on a park bench without the slightest of BG elements…If room was an issue then we could have gone to an arial view with an open bg.Again perspective is off with figures on the ground and there are too many darn cigarette’s in this scene..almost everyone has one…vary the props in scenes..make them work for you.

Panel 4.
This guy just pops in winking!?..It could help alot to put him in bg on panel 3 in bg to introduce him somehow.We just don’t know who it is yet.

panel 5.
Another tilt-panel?..this one would work better if he was actually walking from left to right to lead us to the proceeding panel..might make it a full-body shot to vary panel layouts.His current direction matches panel 2 too much.

panel 6.
Nice shot but now the kid is taller than the locker’s and in panel 5 he was shorter…not a biggy.Also,Plan your body positions completely…his hand looks like it goes into her face…his body perspective also does not match up with the persp’ of the lockers.

panel 7.

This panel at the bottom ends right in the middle?…how are we to continue to the next page if our left to right relationship is cut off in the last panel?…very important to keep the flow going.

I am sorry if it seems I have ripped it apart but i am not saying it isn’t great art…Great storytelling is what makes comics great!not just the art.

J.

I also want to add that everyone has done a great job and I am sorry if my comments have come off rude or insulting which is totally the opposite of what I mean to do with my critique.

J.

Leave a Comment

 

Subscribe to CSBG

Recent Posts

CBI3 Finalist Wilfredo Torres Joins Brown, Golden on “Demon’s Regret”

Friday, March 21st by CBI Administrator  |  One Comment

Idol Thoughts 11/20

Tuesday, November 20th by Brian Cronin  |  One Comment

Idol Thoughts 11/19

Monday, November 19th by Brian Cronin  |  3 Comments

Press Release: Jon Reed Wins CBI3

Friday, November 16th by J Torres  |  2 Comments

The Winner of Comic Book Idol 3 is…

Thursday, November 15th by J Torres  |  3 Comments

Idol Thoughts 11/14

Wednesday, November 14th by Brian Cronin  |  2 Comments

Round 5 Public Poll Open

Wednesday, November 14th by Brandon Hanvey  |  No Comments

Idol Thoughts 11/13

Tuesday, November 13th by Brian Cronin  |  4 Comments

Idol Thoughts 11/12

Monday, November 12th by Brian Cronin  |  3 Comments

Idol Thoughts 1/10

Saturday, November 10th by Brian Cronin  |  One Comment

Browse the Archives